best red hair dye reviews

Best Red Hair Dye: 13 Budget-Friendly Crimson Hues

Are you ready to rock some red locks? Then this post is a great resource for you. Below you’ll find a detailed list of the best red hair dye options out there! Take a look to find the dye that’s right for you.

I’ve mentioned here before that I love dyeing my hair. It’s a fun way to change up my look. One of my favorite looks is vivacious red hair. From a brownish-auburn to electric red, there are dozens of red hair dyes to choose from. Pick the right product can be tricky, so I’ve compiled a list of the best hair dye brands.

Below you’ll find a bit of everything on the red color spectrum. To make things even easier, I’ve divided options up into categories like ‘best box red hair dye’ and ‘ best red hair dye for dark hair’. No matter what you’re looking for, I feel pretty confident that we’ve got you covered!

Best Semi-Permanent and Permanent Red Hair Dye

Arctic Fox Semi Permanent Hair Color Dye 4 Ounce (Poison)

best red hair dye

If you’ve read our recent posts, you know that Arctic Fox is a pretty popular brand. Their super-gentle hair dye has no harmless chemicals, and it actually conditions your hair while you’re using it. Poison, a super vivid red hue, is a semi-permanent dye that doesn’t require any developer. The formula is ready for use right out of the bottle. It’s a great pick if you plan to frequently re-dye your hair, as you don’t have to worry about damage.

Wella Color Charm Liquid Permanent Hair Color 7R/810 Red

best permanent red hair dye

For permanent hair color that’s salon-quality and affordable, Wella is hard to beat. This red hair dye produces a natural-looking red, so it’s great if you want a tamer look. Wella Color Charm is one of my go-to dyes because it’s permanent and doesn’t require constant touch ups. The red dye is less than $5.50 on Amazon, so it’s an absolute steal considering it’s used in salons. I suggest pairing it with the Wella Color Charm 20 Volume Creme Developer to get excellent, professional-looking results.

Matrix Socolor Hair Color #6RV Light Brown Red Violet

I consider Matrix Socolor in Light Brown Red Violet on of the best red hair dyes for a few reasons. First, this brand and specific product are used in salons to achieve perfect, professional results. It’s also very positively reviewed on Amazon by over 200 satisfied buyers. Lastly, the color is unique and bridges the gap between natural red hair and an ultra-bright red look. If this color doesn’t suit you, you can still use the Matrix Socolor formula. Some of their other dyes include Medium Brown Red Copper, Dark Red Blonde, Dark Brown Red Violet, and more. It’s easy to find a red hue that’s right for you with this brand.

Schwarzkopf Ultime Hair Color Cream, 4.2 Mahogany Red

best mahogany red hair dye

If you want a rich red color with a nice glossy finish, Schwarzkopf Ultime Hair Color Cream may be right for you. This very reputable brand offers hair dye that’s designed to leave your hair in good condition. The dye contains their exclusive Intensive Care Elixir that includes pearl essence. Pearl essence is often used in hair and cosmetic products to create a beautiful sheen. Aside from Mahogany Red, Schwarzkopf has an entire Flaming Reds line for you to check out. The other colors in this line include Vintage Red, Cocoa Red, Light Copper Red, and Ruby Red.

Best Temporary Red Hair Dye

Manic Panic Dye Hard Hair Color Styling Gel Vampire Red

best semi-permanent red hair dye

If you want a dark red hair dye without the commitment, try out Manic Panic’s Color Styling Gel in Vampire Red. This is a two-in-one product; it’s a hair color as well as a hair styling gel. The formula is firm holding, so it’s best for use on shorter hair. The color comes right out when you shampoo your hair, so you can use it as often or as rarely as you’d like. As an added perk, this unique non-toxic hair color gel glows under UV black lights. It’s a perfect pick if you’re going to a party or club and want to change things up!

Unique Hair Color Spray, Red

best temporary red hair spray dye

Unique Hair Color Spray is a super vivid neon red temporary color. It comes in an aerosol can, so you get excellent precision when applying it to your hair. It’s ideal if you just want highlights or to color specific sections of your hair. The lighter your hair is, the brighter this red color will look. If you’ve got darker locks, you may need to apply a few layer. Like other temporary hair dyes, Unique Hair Color Spray comes out completely when you shampoo your hair. You can use it for special events or to simply see if red hair is right for you!

Best Red Hair Dye For Dark Hair

Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Color Creme

best red hair dye for dark hair

My natural hair is a very dark brown, and I kept it dyed black for about a decade. When I wanted to give red hair a try, my friend told me about this Garnier Nutrisse dye that would color over dark hair. I honestly didn’t expect this dye to work, but it did a wonderful job. As you can see on Amazon, it’s very highly-rated by hundreds of buyers who also have dark hair. In addition to how effective this dye is, I really love two things about it. One, it doesn’t use bleach to color your hair, so you don’t have to worry about harsh damage. Second, it contains super nourishing ingredients like avocado, shea, and olive oil. If you have dark hair and want red locks, I highly recommend giving this affordable brand a shot.

HiColor Red HiLights Red Permanent Creme Hair Color

best red hair dye that doesn't require pre-lightening

When it comes to the best red hair dye for dark hair, HiColor by L’Oreal is one of the most popular and respected brands on the market. As you can see on Amazon, the product has great reviews from over 200 customers. This thick and creamy dye is designed specifically to work on dark hair to create bold red highlights. It lifts your hair three to four color levels, so you’ll certainly get noticeable results. This unique formula is also available in Copper, so you have two red hues to choose from. At under $6, this highly-regarded formula is a pretty valuable deal.

Manic Panic Semi-Permanent Color Cream, Infra Red

best semi-permanent red hair dye for dark hair

Many Manic Panic hair dyes are designed for use on lightened hair. However, the Manic Panic FAQ page lists several colors that work on dark hair, and Infra Red is one of them. The page states that this color works well on hair that ranges from very dark brown to dark blonde. As per usual, Manic Panic has a very gentle and natural formula that conditions your hair while it dyes it. If you have dark brown or brown hair, expect more of a red tint than a major color change. Another one of their red dyes, Vampire Red, is also designed for use on very dark brown to dark blonde hair. If you want to change things up with zero damage to your hair, try out one of these red Manic Panic hues!

Best Box Red Hair Dye

Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Color Creme, 66 True Red (Pomegranate)

best box red hair dye

Choosing a box red hair dye can feel tricky, but the Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Color Creme reviews are incredibly reassuring. At the link above, you’ll notice this boxed hair dye has over 1,400 reviews and an outstanding star rating. Like the other Garnier Nutrisse dye mentioned above, this one is rich with moisturizers including olive, avocado, and shea oil. It also comes with a small dose of grape seed oil for you to add into the dye for enhanced nourishment. It’s a permanent dye that offers 100% gray coverage, so it’s perfect if you’re looking for something long-lasting. It also comes in shades like Intense Auburn and Dark Burgundy if you want a different red hue.

Garnier Olia Oil Powered Permanent Hair Color, 6.65 Light Garnet Red

best oil formula red hair dye

Yet another Garnier boxed dye tops our list of the best red hair dye! The Garnier Olia formula is newer than the others, so I decided to research it a bit. From what I’ve discovered, this dye is really focused on being very gentle and actually enhancing the condition of your hair. The formula contains a 60% oil blend that treats dryness by hydrating hair and making it look and feel shinier. Despite being ammonia-free, this gentle dye is long-lasting. If you want a box red hair dye that will nourish your locks, you may want to give this one a try.

Revlon Colorsilk Haircolor, Auburn Brown

best long lasting red hair dye

When I had black hair, Revlon Colorsilk Haircolor was my go-to hair dye. At first, I figured all jet black hair dye was the same, and I tried nearly ten brands. However, Colorsilk dye ended up being my absolute favorite. The product description says that you’ll get vibrant multi-tonal results, and this is absolutely true. Even with the black dye, my hair looked vibrant and the color wasn’t flat or dull at all. It also claims to leave hair in better condition, and I truly feel like it does. The results lasted at least six weeks, so it’s definitely a great option for long lasting color. Their Auburn Brown is a perfect pick if you want a somewhat natural looking red color. You may also consider Burgundy, Dark Auburn, or Deep Burgundy. No matter what you pick, I’m confident you’ll like this dye.

L’Oreal Paris Couleur Experte Color + Highlights in a Flash, Light Golden Copper-Brown Ginger Twist

best red hair dye in a box

I remember seeing the L’Oreal Paris Couleur Experte kit in stores. It intrigued me because it’s a two-in-one kit that offers all over color along with highlights. It’s designed to create salon-like results without the cost of a salon, and Amazon buyers are very satisfied with the product. This pick is excellent if you want a truly natural redhead look, as you’ll have rich highlights blended evenly into your new color. According to the instruction, the process only takes about 30 minutes. That’s pretty impressive for the promised results! After reading the Amazon reviews, I can honestly say that this dye has my vote.

Tips For Keeping Red Hair Vivid

In my experience, the only downside to having red hair is that it can fade very quickly. This may be true for many colors, but I noticed red faded quicker than others. Here are some simple tips for getting the most from the best red hair dye you choose.

Sport Your Radiant Red Locks With Confidence

When you use the best red hair dye, you can feel confident that your strands will look stellar. There are so many options on the list above; you’re sure to find something affordable that’s perfect for you. If you have any red hair dye recommendation, questions, or comments, just drop a comment below. I’m happy to discuss all things beauty with you!

Lastly, I’d love for you to take a minute to join BaumBeauty on social media. I post daily about sales, freebies, coupons, and other ‘beauty on a budget’ topics. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram to stay updated!

Amy Baum
Follow me

Amy Baum

Thanks for reading! My name is Amy. I'm a 20-something mother, avid coffee drinker, freelance writer, and makeup junkie. I'm also a sucker for sales, discounts, and saving money. And that's exactly why I'm sharing my cosmetic and beauty adventure on BaumBeauty!

Check out our other sections and my social profiles :)!
Amy Baum
Follow me
Share it:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *